Book Review: ‘But I Am One of You’ by Samrat Choudhury and Preeti Gill

Book Title: But I Am One of You: Northeast India and the Struggle to Belong
Editor(s): Samrat Choudhury and Preeti Gill
Publisher: HarperCollins India
Number of Pages: 316
ISBN: 978-9362138576
Date Published: Aug. 14, 2024
Price: INR 407

Book Review

Nestled in the eastern Himalayas, India’s Northeast is a region of stunning landscapes, diverse cultures, and rich tribal heritage, yet it faces significant challenges in fully integrating its Indigenous communities into the mainstream development narrative. Despite its wealth of natural resources and vibrant cultural identity, the region struggles with weak infrastructure, limited access to markets, social inequalities, and ongoing conflicts, such as the recent unrest in Manipur.

In this connection, “But I Am One of You: Northeast India and the Struggle to Belong“, edited by Samrat Choudhury and Preeti Gill, is a thought-provoking anthology that delves into the complex and layered identities of Northeast India. Through 18 essays, this collection highlights the experiences of individuals who have grown up or lived in the region, offering readers a glimpse into the social, political, and cultural struggles that define this often misunderstood part of India

The book’s contributors offer raw and poignant reflections on their hometowns, from the bustling markets of Shillong to the tranquil rivers of Kokrajhar, weaving together memories and history to provide a deep understanding of the emotional and cultural significance of place. The essays cover a wide range of issues, from ethnic tensions to personal reflections, making this a significant exploration of the multifaceted concept of belonging in Northeast India.

The anthology revolves around the question of identity—who belongs, who doesn’t, and how these lines are drawn. The essays discuss how communities in Northeast India, such as the Meiteis, Kuki-Zo tribes, and Bengali-origin Muslims, navigate a region marked by ethnic conflicts, separatist insurgencies, and political turmoil. The contributors provide an intimate look at how these groups negotiate their identities amid evolving political and social landscapes, often driven by events such as the National Register of Citizens (NRC) and the Citizenship Amendment Act (CAA). These essays paint a vivid picture of the struggle to find belonging in a state marked by deep-rooted tensions.

One of the anthology’s strengths lies in its ability to connect personal narratives with the broader socio-political context of Northeast India. The book features stories that recount the experiences of Gorkhas, indigenous women in Tripura, and the Sikh community in Nagaland, among others. Through these diverse perspectives, the authors highlight the impact of historical and contemporary forces on the daily lives of the people in the region. The essays reflect on issues such as the “othering” of communities, the role of migration in shaping identities, and the marginalization of groups within both Northeast India and the rest of the country.

Check out our Latest Book Reviews

In summary, “But I Am One of You” is a must-read for anyone interested in understanding the complexities of identity, belonging, and conflict in Northeast India. This collection offers a rare and heartfelt insight into a region that is often seen only through the lens of conflict or exoticism, challenging readers to consider the humanity behind the headlines and stereotypes. The book not only provides a rich cultural and historical tapestry of Northeast India but also resonates with universal themes of belonging and self-awareness.

Books are love!

Get a copy now!